Under 25 Kings aren't Worth Mentioning...

[FabulousForum]

David Amber I think Snubbed a lot of kings by not even listing them in the first paragraph.

ESPN - Want to build an NHL team? Start with one of these players - NHL

[gescom]

i don't know... it's a pretty good list.

the only one i think i'd really question is Ilya Kovalchuk over someone like Rick Nash.

[Creeping Death]

Erik Johnson over Eric Staal and Rick Nash? I'll take Nash/Staal everyday over EJ.

[Hipcheck]

Originally Posted by Creeping Death

Erik Johnson over Eric Staal and Rick Nash? I'll take Nash/Staal everyday over EJ.

Totally agreed. And Carey Price? No offense to the writer should the list included bonafide players that have actually proved something already? Price may be the next Pat Roy but as for now it ridiculous for him to be on the list-listed ahead of Getzlaf no less.

[gescom]

Originally Posted by Hipcheck

Totally agreed. And Carey Price? No offense to the writer should the list included bonafide players that have actually proved something already? Price may be the next Pat Roy but as for now it ridiculous for him to be on the list-listed ahead of Getzlaf no less.

if that were the case, you would eliminate Toews, Johnson and Price.

[Unfiltered]

Originally Posted by gescom

i don't know... it's a pretty good list.

the only one i think i'd really question is Ilya Kovalchuk over someone like Rick Nash.

I couldn't agree more. Rick Nash is one of those game changing players. He's got incredible hands for a player his size, and his skating skills equally match his stickhandling abilities.

I would put Nash Top 4 easily, as it's kind of hard to fault Amber's Top 3.

[JEEPKING]

I would take AlexO over Cindy anyday. I don't care of he is 2 years older. IMHO Ovechkin is a more complete player.

[Hipcheck]

Originally Posted by gescom

if that were the case, you would eliminate Toews, Johnson and Price.

So you agree with me then that price shouldnt be on the list?